10 pc quota for economically backward upper castes: Dalit-OBC thinkers weigh in

10 pc quota for economically backward up...

 

Prominent Dalit-Bahujan leaders have criticised the proposal, calling it an election stunt that undermines the Constitutionally-guaranteed interests of their communities.


The Union cabinet’s introduction of a controversial bill to provide 10% reservation for economically backward upper caste people in government higher education institutes and jobs has sparked dissent. That includes opposition from Dalit-Bahujan activists who say the move will threaten the Constitutionally-guaranteed interests of their communities.

R Krishnaiah, a prominent Other Backward Class leader and MLA, told TNM that the move by the BJP-led government is a "meaningless proposal" and an election stunt. "We are dead against the reservations based on economic grounds. They should learn that the reservations are meant for uplifting and protecting the rights of the lower strata of the society, but not a poverty eradication programme," he said.

He further asserted that "there is no provision or condition in the Constitution that accommodates economic criteria-based reservations. Any aggressive move in this regard will see our agitations."

The proposed 10% quota pushes reservations over the 50% cap mandated by the Supreme Court in 1992. Reservations beyond 50% will go against Article 14 (Right to Equality) of the Constitution but is protected from judicial review by the Ninth Schedule.

Krishnaiah acknowledged that poverty exists among upper castes, though he says it should be handled with government welfare schemes, special economic packages and financial assistance for education.

While OBC organisations threatened to protest against reservations for the upper castes, activists like Prof Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd noted that the move could kill the debate over ‘death of merit.’

Speaking to TNM, Kancha Ilaiah noted that the same groups that once argued against OBC reservation are now bringing reservations to the forefront. Kancha Ilaiah said he welcomes the proposal of 10% reservations for economically weaker sections of upper castes as long as it doesn't affect the existing caste-based reservations for SC, ST and OBC communities.

He pointed out that he and other activists "have long demanded government proposal for 100% reservations for all communities based on fresh caste census, for a more inclusive and democratic policy."

“Those who earlier used talked about merit are silent. They should answer the question of merit now. The debate over so-called merit is finished, since their party itself adopted the idea of reservation," he said.

Dr Jilukara Srinivas, writer, scholar and an executive member with the Bahujana Writers Association, said that the move by the BJP government should be seen as an "election stunt" as upper caste voters have been moving away from the party.

Jilukara slammed the alleged double standard of the government, noting said "the same BJP government denied reservations for Muslims, which Sachar Committee has recommended, showing the so-called cap by the Supreme Court."

In November 2017, Andhra government passed a bill in the state Assembly providing a 5% reservation to the Kapu caste, a peasant community, in education and public employment. However, the bill was stalled by the Centre because of the SC cap.

 


PostedOn: 09 Jan 2019 Total Views: 75




NIA Can't Enter AP: Naidu On Jagan Attac...

NIA Can't Enter AP: Naidu On Jagan Attack Case

After preventing CBI from entering AP following the raids on TDP Leaders, CM Chandrababu Naidu declared National Investigation Agency (NIA) can't interfere in the matters related to his state. To the question over NIA handling Jagan Attack Case, Babu replied: 'NIA should come to the state. Centre ha...

17 Jan 2019

Telangana, Andhra govts waive toll tax a...

Telangana, Andhra govts waive toll tax as thousand...

The move is expected to ease long traffic snarls seen at the toll gates on Hyderabad-Vijayawada, Hyderabad-Warangal and other highways since Friday night. With thousands of families living in Hyderabad heading to their native places in both the Telugu states for Sankranti, the Telangana government o...

13 Jan 2019

Hyderabad police seize Chinese manja wor...

Hyderabad police seize Chinese manja worth Rs 10 l...

Over the years, kite flying using Chinese manja (synthetic thread coated with finely crushed glass) has become popular, but it been outlawed as it causes harm to birds. The Hyderabad Police on Saturday conducted simultaneous raids and arrested two people for illegally procuring, stocking and selling...

13 Jan 2019

TRS demands disqualification of 3 MLCs f...

TRS demands disqualification of 3 MLCs for anti-pa...

Council Chairman K Swamy Goud said that he would consult constitutional experts and reserved his decision. The Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) on Saturday presented its argument for the disqualification of three of its MLCs and demanded legal action for 'anti-party' activities as they joined the Con...

13 Jan 2019

Noted banker and AAP leader Meera Sanyal...

Noted banker and AAP leader Meera Sanyal passes aw...

Meera Sanyal had been battling cancer for two years now. Meera Sanyal, AAP leader and former CEO of Royal Bank of Scotland in India, passed away at the age of 57 after a two-year battle with cancer. Meera was born in Kochi in 1961 to Indian Navy Officer Gulab Mohanlal Hiranandani and Banu Hiranandan...

12 Jan 2019

India's second moon mission Chandrayaan-...

India's second moon mission Chandrayaan-2 to be la...

The window to land on the lunar surface is open between March 25 till the end of April, ISRO Chairman K Sivan said. India's second lunar mission Chandrayaan-2 with a lander and rover will be attempted in mid-April, a top space official said on Friday. "We are targeting mid-April to launch Chandrayaa...

12 Jan 2019

How agents trafficking women in Hyderaba...

How agents trafficking women in Hyderabad continue...

Activists working on the ground say that a case is generally registered under Section 420 (Cheating) of the IPC but the agents are let off on bail very easily. It was in October last year that Nasreen Fatima met Ahmadi Begum in Hyderabad’s Shaheen Nagar area. Ahmadi Begum’s daughter used...

11 Jan 2019

GST Council making decision without cons...

GST Council making decision without consulting sta...

"Agenda items should be fixed taking into consideration the requests of the states also," Yanamala Ramakrishnudu said. Andhra Pradesh Finance Minister Yanamala Ramakrishnudu on Thursday lashed out at the Centre and alleged that the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Council was taking decisions unilateral...

11 Jan 2019