SC reserves order on Centre’s plea to drop secret Rafale papers

SC reserves order on Centre’s plea to dr...

The Supreme Court made it clear on Thursday that it will decide first on the preliminary objections raised by the Centre and then go into the facts of the Rafale fighter jet deal case.

A bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi asked the petitioners seeking review of its order to focus on the preliminary objections regarding admissibility of the leaked documents. "Only after we decide the preliminary objection raised by the Centre, we will go into the facts of the case," said the bench, also comprising Justices S K Kaul and K M Joseph.

At the outset, Attorney General K K Venugopal, appearing for the Centre, claimed privilege over documents pertaining to the Rafale fighter jet deal with France and told the Supreme Court that no one can produce them in the court without the permission of the department concerned.

Venugopal referred to section 123 of the Evidence Act and provisions of RTI Act to buttress his claim. He told the top court that no one can publish documents which relate to national security as the security of the State supercedes everything.

The apex court’s bench, headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, asked the government’s top advocate, "What privilege do you claim? They have already produced them in court.”

Upon hearing the Attorney General's submissions, the Chief Justice asked him to file an affidavit claiming the privilege.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, one of the petitioners seeking review, opposed the submission and said that the Rafale deal documents, which AG says are privileged, have been published and are already in public domain. Bhushan said that provisions of RTI Act say public interest outweighs other things and no privilege can be claimed except for documents which pertain to intelligence agencies.

"The CAG report submitted by the government itself contains all details of as many as 10 defence deals. It is untenable on their part to now claim the privilege. Rafale is the only case where they redacted pricing details," Bhushan said.

He said the government had itself leaked some of the documents containing notings by the then Defence Minister (Manohar Parrikar).

Bhushan also submitted to the SC that there is no need for disclosing the source. He said that disclosing the source was not a necessity, as and when matters of public interest are there.

Another petitioner Arun Shourie also argued that, "If AG said that the documents were stolen and photocopied, then it proves that the documents were genuine."

The government urged the Supreme Court to remove from the review petitions the leaked pages of the secret documents related to the Rafale fighter jet deal, claiming privilege.

During hearing, one of the petitioners in the case, Manohar Lal Sharma also questioned as to why no FIR has been registered under the Official Secrets Act if the documents are classified.

There is no government-to-government contract in purchasing Rafale jets as there is no sovereign guarantee extended to India by France in the Rs 58,000 crore deal, Bhushan said. He also said the Press Council of India Act provides provisions for protecting sources of journalists.

Earlier on Wednesday, the government had filed a fresh affidavit in the apex court in the Rafale case, saying that “unauthorisedly-accessed” documents related to “internal secret deliberations” had been presented in a “selective” manner to mislead the court and amounted to damaging national security.


PostedOn: 14 Mar 2019 Total Views: 64




It is nonsense: SC dismisses plea to cou...

It is nonsense: SC dismisses plea to count 100 per...

The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed a PIL seeking 100 per cent matching of Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) slips with Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) during counting of votes on May 23 for Lok Sabha polls. A vacation bench headed by Justice Arun Mishra refused to entertain the plea f...

21 May 2019

Andhra Pradesh, Telangana declare holida...

Andhra Pradesh, Telangana declare holiday on May 2...

The state governments of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana state on Monday declared a holiday on May 23 — the counting day. The Telangana state government said the holiday was declared under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, for all government offices and educational institutions. The Andhra Pr...

21 May 2019

MEIL Proved its superiority in Hydrocarb...

MEIL Proved its superiority in Hydrocarbons sector...

Execution in record time, quality, safety is the key to success HYDERABAD: MAY 18: Hyderabad based MEIL's Hydrocarbon division made an extraordinary beginning in the field. It has completed and commissioned many projects in the last financial year. Oil storage tanks, Gas based power generation units...

20 May 2019

Madras HC grants anticipatory bail to Ka...

Madras HC grants anticipatory bail to Kamal Haasan...

The Madras High Court on Monday granted anticipatory bail to Kamal Haasan in a case filed against him by Hindu Munnani party for his comments on Nathuram Godse. Haasan told the court that his comments "did not incite hatred". Actor-politician Kamal Haasan stirred a controversy during an election cam...

20 May 2019

2 suspected criminals shot dead inside c...

2 suspected criminals shot dead inside car near De...

Two suspected criminals were killed following a shootout between two rival gangs near the Dwarka Mor metro station in South West Delhi on Sunday, the police said. Parveen Gehlot, a resident of Nawada area, and Vikas Dalal had several cases of murders, extortion and robberies registered against them ...

20 May 2019

Hyderabad: LLB student kills mother over...

Hyderabad: LLB student kills mother over financial...

An LLB student from the city has been arrested for killing his sexagenarian mother over a financial dispute. The accused, who attempted to make the death look like an accident, was held following the postmortem report that indicated that the deceased woman’s left kidney had been smashed and th...

20 May 2019

Hyderabad girl gangraped by four persons

Hyderabad girl gangraped by four persons

A 16-year-old minor girl was gangraped several times allegedly by four persons at Jagdevpur in Siddipet district. The incident took place on Wednesday night, but the police is yet to arrest the culprits. On Saturday, several members of Dalit organisations met the district collector and complained to...

19 May 2019

PM Modi Offers Prayers At Kedarnath Temp...

PM Modi Offers Prayers At Kedarnath Temple

Prime Minister Narendra Modi kickstarted his two day trip to Uttarakhand on Saturday by visiting the Kedarnath shrine. He spent half-an-hour offering prayers at the famous temple. Kedarnath Shrine is located at 11,755 ft above the sea level. Tight security arrangement were made in view of PM Modi's ...

18 May 2019