Karnataka 2018 Explainer: K’taka Guv invites Yeddyurappa to form govt, but did he follow guidelines?

Karnataka 2018 Explainer: K’taka Guv inv...

Even as BS Yeddyurappa was sworn-in as the 23rd Chief Minister of Karnataka just hours after the Karnataka Governor Vajubhai Vala invited him to form the government, the Congress-JD(S) combine have challenged his appointment at the Supreme Court.  

On Wednesday, Vajubhai Vala gave the BJP the go-ahead to form the government and asked them to prove their majority on the floor of the House within 15 days.  

Even as the Congress-JD(S) combine argues that they should have been invited to form the government as they had more than the required number, there are no clear guidelines on what the Governor must do in the event of a fractured verdict.  

Addressing a press conference on Thursday night, Union Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad quoted from the Sarkaria Commission, the MM Puncchi Commission and a 2016 Supreme Court order stating, “In every case, it is clear that in case there is any issue, the largest pre-poll alliance is to be invited, after which consideration is to be given to the single largest party that stakes a claim to form the government and finally, to a post poll alliance.”

But is it clear? As Alok Prasanna Kumar writes for Bloomberg Quint, “No article in the Constitution clearly and unequivocally guides his (Governor’s) choice in such a situation.”

What are the options outlined so far?

Sarkaria Commission

Set up in 1983, the Sarkaria Commission came out with its report in 1988 where it reviewed Centre-State relations and suggested changes within the framework of the Constitution. The Commission is the only one to give recommendations on what the Governor should do in case of a fractured verdict.

In its report, the Commission lays out four options on what can be done:

  1. An alliance of parties that was formed prior to the elections
  2. The single largest party staking a claim to form the government with the support of others, including independents
  3. A post-electoral coalition of parties, with all the partners in the coalition joining the government
  4. A post-electoral alliance of parties, with some of the parties in the alliance forming a government and the remaining parties, including independents, supporting the government from outside.

However, these are recommendations and are subject to the Governor's discretion and the person’s decision is final. It is important to note, however, that he does not have complete discretion. It can be challenged if the Chief Minister isn’t qualified or if the appointment is contrary to constitutional provisions.

MM Punchhi Commission

In 2007, the three-member MM Punchhi Commission was set up to look at the roles and responsibilities of various levels of government and review Centre-State relations. It submitted its report in 2010.

The Commission references the Sarkaria Commission report and also lays down guidelines on what can be done in the event of a hung assembly —

(a) The party or combination of parties which commands the widest support in the Legislative Assembly should be called upon to form the Government.

(b) If there is a pre-poll alliance or coalition, it should be treated as one political party and if such coalition obtains a majority, the leader of such coalition shall be called by the Governor to form the Government.

(c) In case no party or pre-poll coalition has a clear majority, the Governor should select the Chief Minister in the order of preference indicated below:

1.    The group of parties which had pre-poll alliance commanding the largest number

2.    The largest single party staking a claim to form the government with the support of others

3.    A post-electoral coalition with all partners joining the government

4.    A post-electoral alliance with some parties joining the government and the remaining including independents supporting the government from outside.

Although the report does go on to state that if specific guidelines regarding post-poll alliances are not laid out, it would result in ambiguity and the Governor would invite the single largest party to form the government.

Given the lack of clear guidelines in the event of a narrow majority, the Punchhi Commission recommends constitutional amendments. “There are no uniformly accepted conventions and this can be remedied by adopting constitutional amendments, which lay down specific guidelines and approaches which ought to be followed by the Governor,” states its report.

SR Bommai v. Union of India

This widely quoted judgement also offers no clear guidelines on what needs to be done in the event of a fractured mandate. The Bommai case says that the floor of the assembly is the best place to test majority, but it makes it clear that its orders were passed in the context of an incumbent CM losing majority during their term.

Paragraph 396 of the judgement states:

We make it clear that what we have said above is confined to a situation where the incumbent Chief Minister is alleged to have lost the majority support or the confidence of the House. It is not relevant to a situation arising after a general election where the Governor has to invite the leader of the party commanding majority in the House or the single largest party/group to form the Government. We need express no opinion regarding such a situation.”

 


PostedOn: 17 May 2018 Total Views: 135




Wiped out in Telangana polls, AAP eyes a...

Wiped out in Telangana polls, AAP eyes a long-shot...

This is the second state election that AAP is contesting in Telangana, but the party’s gateway to South India through the state remains a non-starter. After facing a spectacular loss in the recent Telangana polls, the state wing of the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) isn't backing down. Though they lost...

15 Dec 2018

Will KCR's announcement to enter Andhra ...

Will KCR's announcement to enter Andhra politics i...

KCR announced that he would give a 'return gift' to Chandrababu,while AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owasi has promised support to TDP's rival in Andhra, Jagan Mohan Reddy. The landslide victory of the Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) in the recent Assembly polls in Telangana may have some impact on the polit...

15 Dec 2018

KTR appointed Working President of TRS: ...

KTR appointed Working President of TRS: Is KCR pav...

KCR might have to follow Karunanidhi’s footsteps in dealing with other members of his family, like his nephew Harish Rao. TRS President and Telangana CM K Chandrashekhar Rao appointed his son and Siricilla MLA K Taraka Rama Rao as the Working President (Executive President) of the party on Fri...

15 Dec 2018

K Chandrasekhar Rao appoints Mahmood Ali...

K Chandrasekhar Rao appoints Mahmood Ali as Telang...

Ali, 66, has been with KCR since the latter floated TRS to revive the movement for separate Telangana state in 2001. TRS leader Mohammad Mahmood Ali was on Thursday made the Home Minister of Telangana by Chief Minister and Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) President K Chandrashekhar Rao. Ali, a member...

14 Dec 2018

Explainer: Why KCR’s call for dismissing...

Explainer: Why KCR’s call for dismissing Concurren...

The Concurrent List includes subjects that give powers to both the Centre and state – and for a while now, state list subjects have been shifted to the concurrent list to give greater control to the Centre. Returning to power for a second consecutive term after routing the Congress-led Prajaku...

13 Dec 2018

Big blow to DK Aruna in Telangana as TRS...

Big blow to DK Aruna in Telangana as TRS storms Co...

The incumbent MLA lost to her nephew and TRS candidate Bandla Krishna Mohan Reddy by a margin of 28,260 votes. In a major blow to the Congress in Telangana, senior leader and incumbent Gadwal MLA DK Aruna lost to her nephew and Telangana Rashtra Samiti (TRS) candidate Bandla Krishna Mohan Reddy by a...

12 Dec 2018

In major upset for Cong, Revanth Reddy l...

In major upset for Cong, Revanth Reddy loses in Ko...

The first-time candidate from the TRS defeated the Congress strongman by 9,319 votes. In a surprising turn of events, Patnam Narender Reddy of the Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) secured a victory in the Kodangal constituency in Telangana, defeating incumbent MLA and political heavyweight Revanth Re...

12 Dec 2018

Asaduddin Owaisi meets K Chandrasekhar R...

Asaduddin Owaisi meets K Chandrasekhar Rao, Says K...

A day before the Telangana Assembly elections results are declared, All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) president Asaduddin Owaisi met Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao today. The MIM president went to Pragathi Bhavan, the official residence-cum-camp office of the Telangana chi...

10 Dec 2018